Can Sodium-ion Batteries Propel the Future of Clean Transportation?

Sodium-ion batteries present a promising alternative to ubiquitous Lithium-ion batteries which are marred by issues related to the speed of recharge, safety and raw material sourcing. This guest article by Dr Ashish Rudola explores the subject.

The lithium-ion battery is the highest energy density1 battery technology currently in existence commercially. It is hence no surprise that for electric vehicle (EV) applications, it is the go-to battery if one requires a long driving range per charge as an EV’s range per charge is proportional to its battery’s energy density. 

However, the high energy density offered by lithium-ion batteries comes at a high price. The lead-acid battery, on the other hand, is much cheaper than the lithium-ion battery (about 3-6 times cheaper), though, its energy density is significantly lesser (about 4-6 times lower). 

This means that basing EVs on lead-acid batteries might decrease costs for the customer but it would significantly shorten the mileage of the vehicle per charge. But what is so special about lithium-ion batteries that results in such high energy densities?

Lithium-ion batteries dominate the market currently

At its core, the current lithium-ion batteries have a lithium containing material such as lithium nickel-cobalt-manganese oxide (‘NMC’) as the positive electrode (cathode), graphite as the negative electrode (anode) with flammable organic compounds-based liquid electrolytes. When the battery is charged, lithium ions (Li+) are extracted from the cathode and inserted into the anode. When this battery is actually being used to drive the EV, the Li+ shuttle back from the anode into the cathode. 

The reason why such batteries cost a lot is because of two key reasons: high cost of lithium resources and also the high cost of cobalt that is used in the NMC cathode. Lithium is a scarce element in the earth’s crust – world terrestrial lithium resources estimated at 62 million tonnes.2

The dominant forms of lithium production3 can be from brine (led by South American countries such as Chile) or mined from minerals where Australia is the leading producer. Such scarcity means that supply of lithium will always be an issue, especially if demand increases (this is inevitable with the expected greater future demand for lithium-ion batteries not only for EV applications but also in mobile phones, laptops, grid-storage etc). 

Cobalt is similarly rare in the earth’s crust (global terrestrial cobalt resources at only 25 million tonnes2 and is quite unique in that most of the cobalt production (⁓94 % of global production) occurs as a by-product of other minerals’ production3. This means that the supply and hence price of cobalt will be highly dependent on the demand for the other elements of the principal minerals – this uncertain global cobalt supply-chain is unfavourable for price security. On the other hand, the primary cobalt reserves are located in the geopolitically sensitive Democratic Republic of Congo where unscrupulous mining practices such as child labour can be often used to extract cobalt from the mines.

Sodium-ion batteries as an alternative to lithium-ion batteries

1. Using Abundant Raw Materials – Can a battery then be made with the benefits of the lithium-ion battery, but uses more earth-abundant materials?

The answer to this question could lie in sodium-ion batteries. The sodium-ion battery works exactly in the same manner as the lithium-ion battery, just with the lithium compounds swapped with sodium compounds. Sodium is the sixth most abundant element in the earth’s crust with vast global reserves of sodium minerals: for example, the terrestrial reserves of just soda ash (also known as sodium carbonate) are estimated at potentially 47 billion tonnes.2 Even more appealingly, sodium is present in appreciable quantities in seawater indicating that sodium reserves are effectively infinite on earth. The upshot of this is that there will never be any supply issues for sodium resources, irrespective of demand, for most countries especially those which have a coastline such as India. 

Research interest in sodium-ion batteries really took off from 2011 onwards when the scientific community realised limited lithium resources was a fatal flaw inherent to lithium-ion batteries. Until 2010, there were only 115 scientific papers ever published on such batteries by 2010. In the subsequent nine years, this number grew 50-fold in just nine years, to 5,804.

Of course, as noted in the case of NMC for lithium-ion batteries, the type of cathode, anode and electrolyte used in sodium-ion batteries will ultimately also determine the cost, performance and safety of such batteries. By 2011, since the scientific community was already aware of using earth-abundant elements in batteries, conscious efforts were expended to avoid using costly cobalt in the sodium-ion cathodes. 

As a gauge on what viable sodium-ion cathode materials are based on, Faradion (the first commercial sodium-ion battery company, established in 2011 in the UK) has filed multiple patents on sodium nickel and manganese-based oxide cathodes which do not contain any cobalt. Manganese is a very earth-abundant element and nickel is also present in appreciable quantities in the earth’s crust, with an estimated 89 million tonnes of terrestrial reserves. The energy density of these sodium-ion cathodes has been shown to be almost similar (⁓80%) to that of NMC lithium-ion cathodes. 

Furthermore, the anode used in sodium-ion batteries is also carbon-based, being an allotrope4 of graphite. This material, called ‘hard carbon’, can be conveniently made from high-temperature pyrolysis5 of biomass, or indeed, any oxygen-rich organic material, indicating again infinite resources in-principle. The sodium-ion electrolyte uses less flammable organic solvents – this is made possible because hard carbon anode is chemically compatible with propylene carbonate, an organic solvent with a high flash point. Propylene carbonate is not compatible with graphite anode used for lithium-ion batteries, precluding its use in lithium-ion systems. 

2. Safety – The use of thermally stable solvents means sodium-ion batteries are inherently safe and very unlikely to catch fire, as occurs routinely for lithium-ion batteries using flammable solvents. With reference to safety, sodium-ion batteries can also be discharged to 0 V (zero energy) without any issues; in contrast, lithium-ion batteries can never be discharged to such low voltages as the copper current collector used on the lithium-ion anode side adversely reacts at such low voltage values. 

Hence, lithium-ion batteries always need to be stored or transported at a partially or fully charged state, where a battery is at its most unstable state. This is why there are global regulations which tightly dictate how lithium-ion batteries can be transported (this is the reason why airlines disallow lithium-ion batteries to be checked-in, for example). 

For sodium-ion batteries, 0 V storage and/or transportation is not a problem due to the use of aluminium current collectors on the cathode as well as the anode. The use of aluminium not only enhances the safety of sodium-ion batteries but also increases energy density and reduces the cost of such batteries as aluminium is significantly lighter and cheaper than copper.

3. Comparable Energy Density – Utilising above technical breakthroughs, Faradion has shown energy densities of sodium-ion batteries to be almost comparable (around three-fourths) with that of NMC-based lithium-ion batteries. Of course, the energy density of such sodium-ion batteries are about four times higher than that of lead acid-batteries at crucially, similar cost levels, with significantly longer cycling stability and much higher efficiency.

4. Quick Recharging – In addition, recent internal Faradion data has shown that sodium-ion batteries can be safely charged to 100% of its rated capacity in just under 20 min. This significantly contrasts with the case of lithium-ion batteries (using conventional graphite anodes) as fast charging of lithium-ion batteries can often lead to internal short-circuits and explosions due to ‘lithium plating’6. It should be noted that lithium-ion batteries can be charged fast with alternate anode materials in place of graphite, but these anode materials invariably decrease the energy density of the resultant lithium-ion cells.

Sodium-ion batteries can also show sodium plating if charged too fast. However, with the right combination of its hard carbon anode and patented electrolyte, Faradion has successfully overcome this sodium plating issue, thereby opening the doors to fast charging of its sodium-ion batteries. This favourable result is expected to be particularly important for EV applications as EV owners could recharge their batteries in just minutes, as opposed to hours which is the case with conventional lithium-ion batteries. 

The future of clean transportation in India

The image below provides a bird’s eye view of the differences in the chief metrics between the three types of battery technologies. It can be seen that the sodium-ion battery technology would be very well placed for those EVs demanding up to moderate energy densities such as smaller EVs (e-rickshaws and e-scooters) or e-buses: in these applications, the sodium-ion battery’s cost would be similar to that of the lead-acid battery, but provide 3-4 times the driving range. In keeping with India’s FAME II initiative to aggressively expand the number of such EVs on Indian roads, sodium-ion batteries would be the ideal battery technology to enable this vision to fruition. Faradion is working with think tank Bridge India to raise awareness of this untapped market potential in India.

Differences in chief metrics between lead-acid, lithium-ion and sodium-ion batteries | Source: Wikipedia.

India could establish manufacturing dominance in sodium-ion batteries

From an energy security viewpoint, it is highly relevant to note that no country has yet established manufacturing dominance in sodium-ion batteries as occurs for lithium-ion batteries (China controls worldwide lithium-ion manufacturing capabilities). In the same vein, China also controls the refinement of lithium-ion cathode minerals along with being the leading suppliers of the graphite anode and the electrolyte2 implying that even if lithium-ion cell manufacturing might occur elsewhere, the raw materials required to produce these cells would most probably still have to be imported from China.

But as an exciting opportunity, since the manufacturing process of sodium and lithium-ion batteries is identical including all equipment, the next hot-bed of sodium-ion battery manufacturing could be any country with attractive governmental policies. The window is currently open for a country or region to create sodium-ion supply-chain clusters to take the lead in sodium-ion battery manufacturing as was done by Japan initially in the 1990s followed by South Korea and China for lithium-ion cell manufacturing

This level of technological maturity for sodium-ion batteries has been achieved in just eight years – with a few more years of similarly rapid development, the signs are indicating that the energy densities of commercial sodium-ion batteries would be comparable to those of NMC-based lithium-ion batteries. In the near future, it is realistic to expect that sodium-ion batteries would break through into the long-range eV market.

Sodium-ion battery manufacturing would align well with India’s ‘Make in India’ policy, enabling it to take global ownership of an industry where it may otherwise compete with, or depend on, China.

About the Author:

Dr Ashish Rudola is a battery scientist at Faradion, based in Sheffield, UK. He was earlier a Research Fellow at the National University of Singapore, where he completed his PhD in sodium-ion batteries. He has worked extensively on various sodium-ion cathodes, anodes and electrolytes with several patents and scientific publications in these areas.

Footnotes:

  1. Energy Density is the measure of how much energy can be stored in a given volume of weight
  2. US Geological Survey 2019
  3. Science Direct Report
  4. Allotrope – Another form of the element that occurs in the same physical state. Different forms arise from the different ways atoms may be bonded together
  5. Pyrolysis – Chemically decomposing organic materials at elevated temperatures in the absence of oxygen reference
  6. Lithium Plating – A condition where the lithium ions precipitate as lithium meral on the anode during fast charging instead of being safely inserted into the anode

3 thoughts on “Can Sodium-ion Batteries Propel the Future of Clean Transportation?

  • November 18, 2019 at 4:01 am
    Permalink

    Hopefully the research and development can overcome the technology limitation and find a suitable cathode material that has minimum expansion and contraction in volume during charging and discharging. Once the technology is developed for commercial application, raw material and manufacturing conditions would favor India’s EV dream.

    Reply
    • November 18, 2019 at 6:16 am
      Permalink

      Right, domestic capability and self-reliance for battery and other EV components are going to play a crucial role in determining India’s success in the EV space.

      Reply
  • November 27, 2019 at 5:22 am
    Permalink

    Very interesting and competitive technology.

    Interested in replacing lead acid batteries (SLI, Start-stop, e-bikes, energy storage – residential/micro-grids)

    -Claims that the cells have specific energy of approx. 140 to 160 Wh/kg.
    -Claim that cost could be 30% less than Lithium Iron Phosphate (LFP); use cheaper electrode materials (sodium and hard carbon) and current collector (cheap aluminum vs copper).
    -Claim much safer than Li-ion; can be shipped safely particularly by air.

    Items to discuss:

    -Made on similar equipment and processes as Li-ion batteries which is not cheap; material cost may be cheaper but process costs are not.
    -Manpower skill sets and availability
    -Sodium is highly reactive in air (moisture) so clean room requirements in fabrication have to be as stringent as Li-ion.
    -Electrolyte can be aqueous or non-aqueou/organic (like Li-Ion) Aqueous give low voltage but safer. —Organic gives high voltage but thermal runaway issues.
    Cycle life is limited (~300 at full depth of discharge).

    Batteries need three attributes:

    Performance (voltage, specific energy, energy density, charge and discharge rates)
    Safety (thermal runaway, over heating, recyclability)
    Cost (cost of materials, cost of fabrication, cost of use, cost of disposal)

    Regarding SIB (sodium Ion Batteries)
    You can have safety with commensurate reduction in performance
    Or performance with commensurate reduction in safety
    Both have issues with costs (car in fabrication, clean room requirements) – I am skeptical of their projection that cells will be <<$100/kWh (Note LFP batteries still cost around $250 to $200/kWh so a 30% reduction mean they would be$175 – $140/kWh)
    They still have a lot of development required to compete with lead-acid let alone Li-ion.
    Will be interesting to see how this technology develops. Also there is no reference to TRL level completion .
    https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2017/cs/c6cs00776g#!divAbstract

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.